Asian Annals
HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
 QUICK SEARCH:   [advanced]


     


This Article
Right arrow Extract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Add to Personal Folders
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow Author home page(s):
Felix Unger
W Gerald Rainer
Dieter Horstkotte
Probal Ghosh
Christian L Olin
Denton A Cooley
Elek Bodor
Bruno B Reichart
Roland Schistek
Wolfgang Ade
Juro Wada
Right arrow Permission Requests
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Unger, F.
Right arrow Articles by Wada, J.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow Articles by Unger, F.
Right arrow Articles by Wada, J.
Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann 2000;8:294-301
© 2000 Asia Publishing EXchange Pte Ltd


SPECIAL REPORT

Standards and Concepts in Valve Surgery

Felix Unger, MD, W Gerald Rainer, MD, Dieter Horstkotte, MD, Probal Ghosh, MD, Wilhelm Rutishauser, MD, Eugene Braunwald, MD, Carlos MG Duran, MD, Christian L Olin, MD, Denton A Cooley, MD, Elek Bodor, MD, Bruno B Reichart, MD, Roland Schistek, MD, Ulrich V Oppell, MD, Wolfgang Ade, MD, Juro Wada, MD

A Task Force report of the European Heart Institute (EHI) of the European Academy of Sciences and Arts and the International Society of Cardiothoracic Surgeons (ISCTS)
For reprint information contact: Felix Unger, MD Tel: 43 662 84 1445 Fax: 43 662 84 1343 email: office{at}european-heart-institute.org European Heart Institute, Waagplatz 3, Salzburg A-5020, Austria.

    Introduction
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
With the advent of open heart surgery it has been possible to actively fight valvular diseases. Before World War II there were some reports of operations on the heart, but these operations were rare and anecdotal. Closed tech-niques were performed occasionally in mitral surgery after World War II. After 1952, a major breakthrough occurred with the introduction of artificial valves and coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) surgery for open heart surgery.

Standards are technical specifications that ensure all procedures are understood and widely accepted. Concepts are abstract ideas or new developments that may become standards if widely accepted. The first artificial valves were designed in the 1950s as ball valves, and later as monoleaflet and bileaflet valves in aortic and mitral positions. Biological valves were developed in the 1960s. Open valve-reconstruction and other techniques were introduced in the late 60s. These techniques were used first for mitral stenosis (MS) and later for mitral regurgitation (MR) and homografts.

The standard for valve replacement (VR) is to use extra-corporeal circulation (ECC) with myocardial protection. In most cases, reconstruction of the diseased valve will not result in good long-term results. Therefore, replace-ment with an artificial valve is preferred. Concomitant bypass surgery as indicated is performed. Device selection remains a challenge and must be tailored to the patient in conjunction with valve surgery. There are concepts in reconstructing the aortic valve as well as in designing new valves.

The management, including diagnostic and postoperative treatment, of patients with valvular diseases is complex. Valve selection can play an important role in the long-term outcome.

The following standards are set for surgeons:

  1. Indication
  2. Postoperative management

A previous task force of the American College of Cardiology and the American Heart Association1 gave an excellent basis for classifying and fostering a useful terminology for cardiac surgeons and cardiologists. Demographics, life span, and epidemiologic characteristics of disease have changed globally in the last 30 years. The availability of cardiac surgery worldwide is highly variable and discrepant, with the USA and Europe offering more accessibility to open heart surgery facilities.2


    Types of Artificial Heart Valves in Current Use
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 


    Labeling of Valves
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
The description of the devices must contain the internal and external diameters in millimeters, including cuff, and the geometrical and effective orifice areas in cm2.


    Sizers
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Valve sizers should be exact replicas of the valves, including the sewing ring, to give the surgeon complete information on the exact fitting of the valve in the method the surgeon wants to employ for implantation of the valve. There is considerable sizer discrepancy between different manufacturers for the same nominal size. It is essential that the sizers be of consistent size.


    Sizing
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
The size of a valve should be adapted to the body mass index. Adequacy criterion may refer to the size of the valve as effective orifice area indexed to body surface area or body mass index.


    Indications for Surgical Interventions on Valves
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
The following three groups give an overview of the indications for surgical interventions on valves:

Group I
Surgery is useful and effective based on scientifically acceptable evidence from long-term studies.

Group II
Indications are tailored to the individual situation of the patient. Surgery may be based on conflicting evidence and/or on a divergence of opinion about the usefulness/efficacy.

  1. Weight of evidence/opinion is in favor of usefulness/outcome
  2. Usefulness/outcome is not well established by evidence/opinion

Group III
Surgery is not useful and in some cases may be harmful for patients with contraindications to ECC or otherwise.

To optimize the timing of valve replacement, the balance between natural history, prognosis, and quality of life are major factors. The prognosis depends on the myocardial adaptability to the chronic volume load and blood pressure. The quality of life depends on the symptoms and the possible complication in valve diseases and subjective need of the patient.

Echocardiography, including Doppler techniques, angio-cardiography, computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) may be sufficient tools to give the surgeon enough information for surgical intervention.

Echocardiographic assessment may be further modified with stress/exercise or pharmaceuticals—when indicated.

Ergometry or exercise/stress/pharmacological modifi-cations of catheterization or echocardiography may be needed when earlier tests are equivocal for selection of therapy.


    Selection of Valves for Replacement
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Recommendations for a Mechanical Prosthesis

Recommendations for Valve Replacement With a Bioprosthesis

Thrombectomy of thrombosed mechanical valve and balloon dilatation of early bioprosthetic stenosis have been shown to be effective in selected cases in recent era.

Risk Stratification for Valve Replacement
In a recent publication of the STS National Cardiac Surgery Database, the mortality rate for surgery overall, based on 86,580 patients, is 7.5%Go.3


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Mortality Risks
 
The risk depends on many factors [i.e., salvage status odds ratio (OR 7.1), emergency status (OR 3), reoperation, ejection fraction (EF), gender (OR 1.25), and age (OR 1.1)].


    Surgery in Aortic Valve Diseases
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Aortic Stenosis

  1. The natural aortic orifice area in adults is up to 3 to 4 cm2. The following characterizes the severity of aortic stenosis (AS):

The absolute numbers need to be viewed according to body surface area, peak systolic gradient, and peak velocity against cardiac index.

Transvalvular pressure gradients are not a basis for classification. Valve resistance or pressure loss (mm Hg/mL stroke volume) is an indicator. One mm Hg/mL is a significant pressure loss.

Indications for valve replacement in aortic stenosis:

AVR is indicated in symptomatic patients with angina, dyspnea, syncope, dizziness, arrhythmia or ischemia, who will have symptomatic improvement and a better survival rate after AVR. The outcome with normal left ventricular function or moderate depression is excellent. The operative risk is 2% in elective cases. In elderly patients over 80 years, AVR often provides satisfactory outcome. Those patients usually have additional CAD. In patients with CAD, there are revascularization criteria to be met as well.

To identify the pathologic adaptation, different stress tests are necessary (i.e., radionuclide ventriculography and dobutamine/stress echocardiography). The progression of the valvular obstruction is indicated by a pressure loss of 1 mm Hg/mL of stroke volume. The progression of calcified aortic valve disease (AVD) is usually rapid, making early intervention necessary.

The following describes groups who require AVR with an artificial valve using ECC:

Valve reconstruction is a concept but rarely done, except in children/adolescents with a noncalcified aortic valve.

In asymptomatic patients the decision is controversial as surgery and prostheses may jeopardize the status of asymptomatic patients.

Concomitant coronary disease is very common. For CABG the criteria for revascularization should be met. Surgical valvotomy may be indicated in rare instances. Ultrasonic decalcification and valvotomy may be discussed in patients over 85 years and in patients with a small aortic root. It may provide acceptable early results but poor long-term outcome due to progressive cuspal retraction.

Aortic Regurgitation
The main feature for consideration in AR is the volume load of the LV. Acute aortic insufficiency mandates intervention in patients with acute endocarditis or acute failure of the valve with a massive regurgitant volume to the LV, which previously was of normal size. Acute chamber dilatation results in decreasing forward volume. AR may also be caused by aortic root dissection. Acute AR is a surgical emergency, which requires prompt identification, management, and surgery.

Echocardiography confirms the diagnosis. Cardiac catheterization needs to be performed when the diagnosis is uncertain and if assessing the coronary arteries is an important component. CT is indicated in acute dissections.

In chronic AR, the diagnosis is confirmed by echocardio-graphy and TEE, exercise testing angiography, and cardiac catheterization. The timing of operation depends on the degree of AR, volume load, and LV function.

VR is performed on ECC with artificial valves and in dissections with a conduit or reconstruction of the valvular apparatus. Cusp-sparing procedures and intravalvular implantation of prosthesis are used in suitable patients.

In AR, VR is used in patients who have a regurgitation fraction greater than 0.3 and symptoms of dyspnea, reduced exercise, arrhythmia, or with documented exhausted myocardial adaptability to the volume load (EF, 0.55; fractional shortening, 27%; end-systolic volume index (ESVI), 60 mL/m2; end-diastolic volume index (EDVI), 200 mL/m2; and left ventricular end-diastolic diameter (LVEDD), 70 mm). If there is no increase in the left ventricular EF under stress, then that is an indication of an exhausted load adaption.

Indications:

Combined Coronary Artery Bypass Surgery and Aortic Valve Replacement
Combined procedures, especially in elderly patients, are increasing. Thirty percent of all valve procedures in the western world are combined with CABG.


    Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Mitral Stenosis
Surgery on the mitral valves has been performed for many years. Different closed techniques have been applied since the 1940s to 1950s but valvotomy, including closed valvotomy, still needs improvement. The outcome in mitral valve surgery is still challenged by prostheses.

The average mitral valve area is 4 to 5 cm2 in an adult. A valve area under 2.5 cm2 may cause symptoms. Indication for replacement depends on echocardiography (TTE, TEE) and cardiac catheterization. All significant stenosis should be defined as mitral valve orifice of area (MVOA) in cm2/m2.

Anticoagulation is recommended in patients with atrial fibrillation, patients with a prior embolic event, and patients with severe mitral stenosis (MS) and left atrial enlargement ( 55 mm). MVR is recommended with preservation of the papillo-annular continuity. Balloon valvotomy is the recommended alternative, depending on the morphology of the valve structure.

Patients with MS:

VR is necessary if the morphology is not/cannot be amended with balloon valvotomy. If the right heart system is insufficient, the right ventricular (RV) end-diastolic diameter is 17 mm/m2, or the result in spiroergometry is in Weber Class B and C, surgery is necessary. Pulmonary vascular resistance is not a parameter for the indication to surgery or for the prognosis in the postoperative follow-up.

Indications:

Mitral Regurgitation
The indication for surgery is present when there is a significant volume of mitral regurgitation (MR). The indication is determined by the left ventricular systolic function, the diastolic pressure, the systolic volume, and pulmonary artery pressure at exercise.

Acute MR results from an overload of the LV. The preload of the LV and the afterload of the right ventricle are increased. Special attention is given in mitral valve regurgitation after acute myocardial infarction (MI) and myocardial ischemia (ischemic MR).

Mitral surgery in MR may be performed by reconstruction. If this is not possible, VR with an artificial valve is recommended. The diagnosis is established by TTE, TEE, 3-D echo. Coronary angiography is necessary prior to surgery in patients who are over 40 years of age and are at risk of CAD.

Reconstruction should be considered in patients with MR. The surgical intervention should be performed before permanent atrial fibrillation or left atrial dilatation 55 mm sets in. In VR the subvalvular structures should be conserved as standard.

Indications:

Mitral Valve Repair

Mitral valve repair may be secured with a mitral ring. However, a ring reinforcement is not essential in all cases of mitral reconstruction.

Concomitant Coronary Bypass Surgery and Mitral Repair
The indication is composed by the indication for CABG, MS, MR, and mitral valve repair. Mitral repair is an option in MR after MI with chordal dysfunction.

Ablation Procedures During Surgery
Ablation procedures in patients with atrial fibrillation are concepts that might have a clinical significance.

Left Atrial Volume Reduction
Several left atrium (LA) volume reduction procedures have been used for giant LA ( 60 mm) which may not always have significant impact on outcome.


    Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Aortic and mitral valve replacements (DVR) are indicated in highly selective surgical groups. The combination of aortic replacement and mitral reconstruction is common as well as concomitant CABG. DVR and tricuspid annuloplasty are indicated under certain circumstances. TV reconstruction should be performed in all cases with preoperative significant tricuspid regurgitation (TR).

Group I. Patients with a NYHA functional Class II to IV symptoms: the patient's condition is determined by the most severe valvular disease, where one of the double valve replacements has a leading indication in group I or II.


    Tricuspid Disease
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Recommendations for Surgery in Tricuspid Regurgitation

The replacement of the TV by means of artificial valve should be a final consideration if TV repair fails.


    Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Valve surgery in pregnancy is a very difficult and complex undertaking. Surgery should be delayed as long as possible with the goal to have a viable fetus. Better fetal salvage rate and quality have been observed with closed mitral valvotomy or balloon mitral dilatation for critical MS in pregnant women.

Caesarean section may be performed concomitantly. Intervention needs to be considered only in low output syndrome. Volume overload related crises are usually ob-served around the 20th week of gestation and during labor.

Bypass technique should be with high flow and warm perfusion.


    Valve Surgery in Infective Endocarditis
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Acute endocarditis leads to deterioration of the valves and is complicated by emboli.

Valve reconstruction has been shown to be feasible with encouraging results in selected cases in recent years.


    Management with Prosthetic Heart Valves
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
Recommendations for Anticoagulation Therapy in Patients With Prosthetic Heart Valves:
Go


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Group I.
 
Group II. Warfarin, INR 3.5 to 4.5 in high-risk patients should be administered when aspirin cannot be used.

Recommendations for Follow-up of Patients With Prosthetic Heart Valves

Indications for Reoperation

Recommendations for Surgery in Prosthetic Endocarditis


    Acknowledgment
 
Contributions by Drs. B. Gersak, N. Poirier, and H. Schulte are acknowledged.


View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Appendix 1. Mechanical Valves
 

View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Appendix 2. Biological Valves
 

View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
Appendix 3. Valves in Current Use
 

    References
 TOP
 Introduction
 Types of Artificial Heart...
 Labeling of Valves
 Sizers
 Sizing
 Indications for Surgical...
 Selection of Valves for...
 Surgery in Aortic Valve...
 Surgery in Mitral Diseases
 Surgery in Multivalvular Disease
 Tricuspid Disease
 Valve Surgery in Pregnancy
 Valve Surgery in Infective...
 Management with Prosthetic Heart...
 References
 
  1. Bonnow RO, Carabello B, de Leon AC, Edmunds LH, Fedderly BJ, Freed MD, et al. Guidelines for the management of patients with valvular heart disease. ACC/AHA task force on practice guidelines. Circulation 1998;98:1949–84.[Free Full Text]

  2. Unger F. Worldwide survey on cardiac interventions 1995. Cor Europaeum 1999;7:128–46.

  3. Jamieson WRE, Edwards FH, Schwartz M, Bero JW, Clark RE, Grover FL. Risk stratification for cardiac valve replacement: National Cardiac Surgery database. Ann Thorac Surg 1999;67:943–51.[Abstract/Free Full Text]





This Article
Right arrow Extract Freely available
Right arrow Full Text (PDF)
Right arrow Alert me when this article is cited
Right arrow Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Right arrow Email this article to a friend
Right arrow Similar articles in this journal
Right arrow Alert me to new issues of the journal
Right arrow Add to Personal Folders
Right arrow Download to citation manager
Right arrow Author home page(s):
Felix Unger
W Gerald Rainer
Dieter Horstkotte
Probal Ghosh
Christian L Olin
Denton A Cooley
Elek Bodor
Bruno B Reichart
Roland Schistek
Wolfgang Ade
Juro Wada
Right arrow Permission Requests
Citing Articles
Right arrow Citing Articles via Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Right arrow Articles by Unger, F.
Right arrow Articles by Wada, J.
Right arrow Search for Related Content
PubMed
Right arrow Articles by Unger, F.
Right arrow Articles by Wada, J.


HOME HELP FEEDBACK SUBSCRIPTIONS ARCHIVE SEARCH TABLE OF CONTENTS
ANN THORAC SURG ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG
J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG ICVTS ALL CTSNet JOURNALS